Bearded man in a navy suit, standing with his hands clasped against a dark backdrop.

Property Management In A Shifting Austin Market

  • Kasey Jorgenson
  • July 8, 2026

Wally Harwood is a broker associate at Jorgenson Real Estate, a lifelong Austinite, and the designated broker for a property management company he co-founded. In this episode of Real Estate, Straight Up, he and Kasey Jorgenson take on the question a lot of Central Texas owners are facing: if the house isn't selling for what you need, should you keep pushing or rent it out? Wally's answer is to run the numbers. For some owners, a small monthly shortfall on a rental beats writing a large check at closing.

Key takeaways

  • If you bought near the top and selling now means bringing money to closing, renting can be the easier path. Wally's example: a few hundred dollars a month instead of a $50,000 check one time.
  • A rented home keeps paying down your mortgage while you wait a couple of years to see where the market goes.
  • Kasey noted that under current rules, a home that was your primary residence for two of the previous five years may still be sold without being taxed as an investment property. That can leave room for two to three years of renting.
  • Recommending that a client rent instead of sell can be the fiduciary move, even though the agent earns far less.
  • Good property management is mostly quiet. When owners don't hear from their manager, things are usually fine.
  • A newer home farther out can look cheaper on paper, but higher tax rates, tolls and commute time can make the monthly cost about the same as an older home closer in.

Should I rent my house or sell it in a slow market?

Kasey said many homes are sitting longer now, and some end up vacant while the owners decide whether to keep trying to sell or rent them out. Wally frames it as a cash question. If you bought when prices were very high, selling now might cost you money at closing, and that may have been your next down payment.

"So is it a lot easier to write a two, three, four hundred dollar check every month than write a fifty thousand dollar check one time?" Wally asked. Meanwhile the tenant is covering most of the mortgage and the loan balance keeps going down. In a couple of years you can look again and decide. "It's a whole lot better to have somebody paying most of your mortgage and somebody keeping an eye on your property than the other alternatives," he said.

Kasey added a tax point he's shared with his own clients. As the law is currently written, if the home was your primary residence for two of the previous five years, you can still sell without the tax treatment of an investment property. That can give an owner two to three years of rental income while the market shifts. Confirm your own situation with a tax professional. If you're weighing both paths, our guide to selling a home in Central Texas and a home valuation are good places to start.

Is it bad for my agent to suggest renting instead of selling?

No. Both Wally and Kasey see it as the opposite. Wally said that when an agent offers renting as an option, knowing they will earn much less, the client sees a fiduciary giving advice, not someone chasing a commission. "It is sometimes the fiduciary move, even though the commissions are way less," Kasey said.

What does a property manager actually do for a landlord?

Wally said the work is more than collecting rent: systems and software, repairs, and details that never come up in a sale. A home sale might mean three months with a client. Property management is a years-long relationship, and the calls usually come when something breaks and someone has to pay.

That's why quiet is good. "No news is good news in property management," Wally said. He got his start helping manage his dad's rentals, including a duplex on Austin's east side and a property in Temple. His summary of the job for investors: "Toilets, termites, and tenants."

Is a cheaper house farther from Austin really cheaper?

Not always. A house may cost less because it's 20 minutes farther from everything, and buyers often miss the taxes. "As you get further out, those tax rates are gonna be smacking you in the face more often than not," he said. An older home closer in may carry a better tax rate, so the monthly payments can end up similar. Our guide to property taxes, MUDs and PIDs explains why rates vary so much.

Kasey adds tolls to the math. If a toll road is your main way in, total up what you spend each month just on your commute and treat it as part of your payment. For younger buyers who want to be near downtown nightlife but can't afford to live there, he suggests an "Uber test": what will a ride downtown cost twice a week from that house?

Wally also tells out-of-town buyers, like recent clients looking around Pflugerville, to drive downtown and back to get oriented, since there's no street grid outside downtown. His goal: "I don't want them to buy, and then six months later calling me and be like, Wally, we hate it over here, it's too far."

How do I choose an Austin neighborhood if I'm moving here?

Start with your own life, not someone else's favorite spot. "Every buyer has different needs and different things that they want," Wally said. Where you work matters. He still has many buyers moving for jobs near the Tesla factory, where the eastern suburbs are still growing. Going north and west, new builds are even farther out. Kasey pointed out that North Austin and Round Rock have a different feel than South Austin, and he cited an Austin economic development study showing more than 100 people a day are still moving to the region.

Wally's own favorites are central: the South Austin streets between Congress and South First, like Mary and Elizabeth, plus Hyde Park and Rosedale. He likes the old 1930s and 40s houses, big trees and walkability. "It's rare to find something walkable," he said. Those areas are expensive to buy, but renting there can still be doable, and buyers who rent first tend to buy with more confidence. For more on areas, see our relocation guide and city and neighborhood guides.

If you're deciding whether to rent or sell, or you're moving to Austin and want a local's read on neighborhoods, reach out to Wally Harwood or any Jorgenson Real Estate agent. You can hear more conversations like this one on the Real Estate, Straight Up podcast.

Questions from this episode

Should I rent out my house instead of selling at a loss?

It depends on the numbers. Wally Harwood's rule of thumb is to compare a small monthly shortfall on a rental with the one-time check you'd write to sell. Renting keeps the mortgage getting paid down and lets you look again in a couple of years.

Can I rent my home for a while and still sell it without investment-property taxes?

Kasey Jorgenson explained that under current rules, a home that was your primary residence for two of the previous five years can generally still be sold without being taxed as an investment property. That can allow two to three years of renting. Confirm your situation with a tax professional.

Are homes farther from Austin really cheaper?

Sometimes only on paper. Wally said tax rates are often higher farther out, and tolls and commute time add to the monthly cost.

What does a property manager handle?

Rent collection, repairs, tenant communication and the systems behind them. Wally summed it up as "toilets, termites, and tenants," and said that in property management, no news is good news.

Listen to the episode

In this episode

Related

Full transcript

Read the full transcript

Work With Us

Contact our team today to get started on your real estate journey.

Follow Us on Instagram